T-Mobile and AT&T now price their plans close enough that a single feature can decide it. AT&T is about $5 a month cheaper for a single line at the mid and top tiers. T-Mobile's T-Mix plans let you spend Picks on streaming services AT&T doesn't include, and its mid-band 5G is faster in most cities.
The short version
- Cheaper at the mid and top tiers, and better in rural areas → AT&T.
- Fastest city 5G, cheapest entry plan, streaming you pick with Picks → T-Mobile.
- Most hotspot → tied at 250GB on the top plans (Elite 2.0 and T-Mix Loaded).
Plans and prices, one line with AutoPay
| T-Mobile | AT&T | |
|---|---|---|
| Entry | T-Mix Saver $45/mo (Standard $55) | Value 2.0 $50/mo |
| Mid | T-Mix More $75/mo | Extra 2.0 $70/mo |
| Top | T-Mix Loaded $95/mo | Premium 2.0 $90/mo |
| Highest tier | No equivalent | Elite 2.0 $110/mo |
| Hotspot | Standard: unlimited at 3G · More: 60GB · Loaded: 250GB | Value: 3GB · Extra: 50GB · Premium: 100GB · Elite: 250GB |
| Price guarantee | None listed for T-Mix (the 5-year lock was on Experience plans, now closed to new customers) | None |
| Taxes and fees | Extra | Extra |
AT&T's AutoPay discount needs a bank account; paying by debit card costs $5 more a month. T-Mobile adds a $5.49 per-line regulatory and telco recovery fee from October 12, 2026, on top of taxes.
Families: four lines
Per line, AT&T runs $30 on Value 2.0, $40 on Extra 2.0, $50 on Premium 2.0 and $70 on Elite 2.0. T-Mix Standard is $25 a line at four when you transfer your numbers ($100 total; $115 otherwise), which makes it the cheapest four-line option of the two if you can live with 3G-speed hotspot and lower priority.
Coverage and speed
AT&T's LTE network reaches more rural areas, especially in the South and Midwest. T-Mobile's mid-band 5G is faster in most cities and suburbs, and its low-band 5G covers more ground than AT&T's 5G. Indoors in rural areas, T-Mobile's low-band signal is where most complaints come from.
How to read each map, and where each one overstates service.
AT&T coverage map →Perks and travel
- T-Mobile T-Mix More gives each line 2 Picks (Netflix Standard with ads costs one) and 5GB of high-speed data abroad.
- T-Mobile T-Mix Loaded gives 3 Picks (Hulu or T-Satellite cost one each), 15GB of high-speed data in 215+ countries and 30GB in Canada and Mexico.
- AT&T Extra 2.0 covers the US, Canada and Mexico; Premium 2.0 adds 20 Latin American countries.
- AT&T Elite 2.0 adds 20GB in 210+ destinations and one free tablet and watch line per phone line.
Bottom line
Pick AT&T if you spend time outside metro areas, want the lower bill, or travel mainly to Mexico and Latin America. Pick T-Mobile if you're mostly in cities, would pay for Netflix or Hulu anyway, or want to choose your own streaming perks. If you're paying $70 to $100 a month for either, an MVNO on the same network costs a fraction of that.
Cricket and Mint use AT&T's and T-Mobile's towers from $25–$30/mo.
Best MVNO plans →Frequently asked questions
Is AT&T or T-Mobile cheaper? +
Which has better coverage, AT&T or T-Mobile? +
Which is better for hotspot? +
Which is better for international travel? +
Keep reading
All guidesOne email when a carrier raises rates, drops a plan, or launches a deal worth switching for. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Jean writes ShopCellPlans' reviews. He compares carrier plans using each carrier's own published prices, its FCC broadband labels and reporting from named outlets, and ranks them on the bill you actually get, taxes and fees included, not the price on the ad.




